“Confronted with the after-school drama, we should permit the set up of video surveillance inside colleges,” estimated in the columns of Le Parisien Grégory Canal, co-president of the Paris Liberté group. The primary opposition group, led by Rachida Dataoffered this Tuesday its proposal to put in cameras in 620 Parisian colleges.
Because the begin of 2026, 78 brokers have been suspended, together with 31 for suspicion of sexual violence in Parisian colleges, revealing a structural drawback. Nonetheless, is the opposition’s plan to massively deploy cameras relevant in view of the rules of the national commission for information technology and freedoms (CNIL)chargeable for the safety of non-public knowledge? Christophe Daadouch, a lawyer specializing in minors’ rights, is categorical: because it stands, these overly normal proposals don’t make it potential to respect the person freedoms of kids and the academic group. Explanations.
What does the Paris Liberté group provide?
This includes putting in round 1,500 cameras, or two to 3 per institution, for an quantity estimated by the group at slightly below ten million euros. “The cameras can be positioned within the passage areas, which might notably permit visibility within the corridors, on entry to the bathrooms or in distinctive circumstances in additional delicate areas resembling nap rooms. To make sure the calmness of the day,” Grégory Canal explains to Le Parisien.
Elected officers are relying on the dissuasive facet of the system and are imagining an experimental part in a number of colleges per district earlier than a potential generalization.
What does the CNIL say concerning the presence of cameras in colleges?
“The varsity isn’t a public place within the sense that you simply can’t enter it like that, its inside areas are non-public, within the authorized sense of the time period,” explains Christophe Daadouch. On its website, the CNIL explains that it’s potential to movie the entrances to the institution and the circulation areas. “It’s excluded, besides in distinctive circumstances (academic institutions victims of frequent and repeated malicious acts), to movie the dwelling areas of the institutions (playground, playground, multipurpose room, classroom, canteen, lobby, academics’ room, bathrooms and their entry space, video games room, altering room and their entry space and so on.) throughout the opening hours of the institution: college students like academics and different workers of the institution have the precise to respect for his or her lives non-public,” the fee instantly provides.
The set up of cameras have to be “detailed and never generalized”, analyzes Christophe Daadouch, who doesn’t hesitate to explain as “demagogic”, a proposal which “rides on the anxiousness of fogeys”. “Once we take into account that to guard kids, the digital camera have to be widespread as a result of we assume that kids are in peril all over the place and on a regular basis, we’re breaking down the barrier between public house and personal house,” believes this lawyer. The institution of such a system would represent “a disproportionate assault on particular person freedoms. »
How efficient are cameras in coping with sexual violence in opposition to kids?
The CNIL additionally recollects that “the usage of cameras should stay restricted and represent a complementary means to different safety measures (resembling surveillance by academic workers). » The cameras don’t movie all angles and recovering their knowledge is tedious and would require numerous extra work for the top of the institution. “A digital camera doesn’t stop details from taking place, it presumably helps to elucidate them,” additionally provides Christophe Daadouch. The top of the institution must be constantly in entrance of his display to watch. And, at greatest it permits us to query after the very fact, however generally years later”
The true reflection available is round recruitment insurance policies and human management, in keeping with this lawyer, who mentions for instance the certificates of excellent reputation for working with minors, which matches in the precise route. He additionally paradoxically mentions that whether it is essential to equip all of the areas which welcome kids from the nursery, to the kid safety houses, together with the household assistant and the childminder, “it could be less complicated to put in Go Execs immediately on the kids…”
All our information on child crime
The 20 million euro motion plan of the brand new socialist mayor Emmanuel Grégoire, which doesn’t present for the set up of cameras, was lastly adopted by the Paris Council on Tuesday, after heated debates with the opposition.
